Why Some Stories Move Us

On restraint, contradiction, consequence, and what we owe the people we write about.

The same scene can break one person open and leave another completely cold.

You’ve felt this. A film, a book, a story someone told at a dinner table — and you were wrecked by it, and the person next to you was fine. Or the reverse: everyone around you is crying and you’re sitting there dry-eyed, not unmoved exactly, just somehow not inside it the way they are.

The easy answer is that we’re all different. I don’t think that’s what’s happening. Some stories are built to move people and some aren’t, and the difference isn’t luck or chemistry. It’s craft: specific, repeatable choices that either open a door or keep it shut.

I’ve been thinking about five of them.

A story moves us when the teller holds back.

There’s a version of emotional storytelling that spends everything up front. The writer cries first, loudest, most visibly — and the reader watches the crying from a comfortable distance, nodding along, never quite getting in.

The version that works does something different. It withholds. Not information, since withholding information is just a trick, but the emotional release. It makes the reader carry something longer than feels comfortable. Then, when the release finally comes, it arrives as catharsis, not report.

The best storytellers understand that restraint isn’t hiding. It’s choosing when to spend what you have. Hold back, and the audience leans in. Spend early, and they sit back. We want what we haven’t been given yet.

Most writers don’t feel too much. They show it too soon.

A story moves us when it lets someone feel two things at once.

The impulse to manage the audience is understandable. You want them to feel the right thing. So you make the character angry, or sad, or determined, one clean, legible emotion at a time.

But real people don’t work that way. Real people are angry and heartbroken simultaneously. They’re relieved in the middle of grieving. They laugh at the exact wrong moment because the laugh and the grief arrived at the same time from different directions.

A story that holds only one emotion at a time isn’t quite lying. It’s simplifying, and the audience can feel it even if they can’t name it. Something is too easy, too readable. The character has been flattened into a feeling rather than allowed to be a person.

The version that moves people trusts the audience to hold contradiction. It doesn’t explain the two feelings. It puts them in the room together and lets the tension do its work. Managing the audience is what flattens a scene.

A story moves us when someone changes, not just feels.

A feeling is a moment. A change is a consequence. And consequences are what we remember.

Most stories end at the feeling. The character cries, or embraces someone, or stands at a window looking out at something meaningful. And it can be beautiful. But it doesn’t stay with us the way a change does, the kind that has to be earned, that costs something, that we can watch ripple forward into how the person moves through the world afterward.

Change is hard to write because it has to be set up long before it arrives. The reader has to know what it would cost this specific person to change — what they’d have to give up, what would have to break in them first. Without that setup, the change reads as convenient instead of inevitable. The release comes, and then it evaporates.

The question worth asking at every major turn in a story: what is different now? Not what did this character feel, but what will they do differently because of it? If the answer is nothing, the scene might be beautiful and it might be cuttable. Usually both.

A story moves us when the questions are braver than the answers.

We inherit story shapes without really choosing them. The familiar arc — setup, complication, climax, resolution — is so deeply embedded in how we think about narrative that it can start to feel like physics rather than convention. Like the way stories have to work.

But the arc is a choice. And it carries assumptions. It assumes that stories build toward a single release point, that tension resolves rather than recurs, that an ending is the point of the telling, not just a place where the telling stops.

Some of the most honest work I’ve encountered refuses that shape entirely. Not as a stylistic statement, but because the experience it describes has no climax and no resolution. It has recurrence. Return. The same question asked again with slightly different hands.

The shape you choose tells the reader what kind of truth you’re after. A story that builds to a moral is making a different claim than one that circles back to the same unresolved ache from a new angle. Neither is better. But only one of them is willing to let the question be braver than the answer.

Ask whether the shape you’re using is actually the shape of your story, or just the shape you were taught.

Ethical storytelling isn’t softer storytelling. It’s the reason the story works.

Every story about real experience involves real people. Sometimes they appear directly. Sometimes they appear refracted through a character, a composite, a scene that’s technically fictional but obviously about someone specific. And there’s a question every writer has to sit with at some point: what do I owe the person this is made from?

The legal answer is easy: don’t defame, obscure identities, change names. The craft answer is harder. If someone in your life asks to be made less recognizable, and you can’t do that without losing what makes the piece true, that’s not a legal problem. That’s a failure of the writing. The story hasn’t found a way to be honest without being cruel, which means it hasn’t found the right form yet.

There’s a story I keep thinking about. A woman named Naomi works her way up from the kind of job where the host’s father pressed money into her hand at the door — forty dollars, in front of everyone — so everyone could watch her be paid. She kept the bill. She kept her grandmother’s handwritten card where she’d see it. She didn’t spend the forty dollars.

Five years later she’s in a different room entirely. The same people who treated her like the help need something from her. What strikes me about the story isn’t the reversal. Reversals are satisfying but cheap. It’s the detail that earns it: the father called her the girl, and someone said Naomi back to him. Made him say the name. And by the end she has sixty-six stores named for her grandmother.

Nobody gets the easy version. Nobody comes through the back door.

That story lands because it refuses to skip anything. The forty dollars is still in the story. The name is still in the story. The grandmother’s handwriting is still in the story. Nothing was cleaned up to make the arc smoother. And because nothing was cleaned up, you believe every word of it.

That’s the question I’d leave you with.

Think of one scene you’ve been meaning to tell. Name the person in it who isn’t you. Ask yourself: would they recognize themselves, and are you all right with the answer?

That question is the ethics of storytelling. It’s also the reason the story lands, or doesn’t.

If there’s a story of your own you’ve been meaning to tell, a Story Conversation is a free place to start finding the words. And if you’d like more letters like this one, they arrive slowly from the house.

First published in Letters from the house.

Next
Next

Healed and Hurting at the Same Table